Considering that Lake Atitlan is one of the most popular destinations in all of Central America, Casa Colonial is a great balance of price and accommodations. You can certainly stay in fancier places around the lake, and you can definitely pay a lot more, but Casa Colonial will give you what you need without emptying your wallet. Oh, and did I mention the people are great? The people are GREAT. I liked that the lobby is open to the street and doubles as JC's paddle board shop. The marinas are 5 minutes away, there's a great tienda right next door, and anything you could want in food, drink, coffee, sweets, or souvenirs is nearby. Go ahead, click on Reserve.