Unique is a great description, and this is exactly what we were looking for.
First, the Old Stagecoach Inn building itself has plenty of character, starting with the front sitting area that encourages visitors to talk / read / work on a puzzle with a cup of tea / coffee / lemonade. The character extends to the rooms, which each have a different style, and we followed the description to specifically chose one with a "more romantic, historic feel".
Second, the breakfasts were incredible, and encouraged us to indulge far more than we should have. There are full restaurants that would not have produced the quality of these meals, and that is another benefit of staying at independent properties that take pride in their work.
We got to know the staff fairly well over just a few days, and not only to unique and character apply, but we felt welcomed as guests in a home rather than customers.
Waterbury itself has a lot to offer for a quiet getaway, with plenty of restaurants in walking distance, a great bookstore just around the corner, many boutique shops, as well as Burlington, Montpelier and Stowe just a short drive away.
I hestitate to post such a glowing review, because the last thing we want is too much competition when scheduling our next stay.